Losing someone after a work injury can leave you with painful questions and urgent decisions at the same time. You do not have to sort out Arizona workers’ compensation, death benefits, and a possible wrongful death claim alone. Arizona’s Work Injury Firm offers a free consultation at (877 ) 370-5788, and there is no fee unless benefits are secured.
A careful starting point after a fatal work injury
After a fatal work accident, it is understandable to want straightforward answers without being rushed. Our practice is limited to Arizona workers’ compensation. That focus matters when a death claim may involve both the workers’ compensation system and a separate claim against someone outside the employer.
A work-related death can affect a household in immediate and lasting ways. Family members may be asked for information by an employer, an insurance carrier, medical providers, or others while they are still grieving. You can take time to understand what is being requested and why. Getting advice early can help you protect the workers’ compensation claim and identify whether another party may be responsible.
Snow Carpio & Weekley, PLC represents injured workers and surviving families across Arizona, including Phoenix, Tucson, Yuma, Flagstaff, Mesa, Glendale, Scottsdale, Mohave County, and Lake Havasu. A free consultation is a place to discuss what happened, who was involved, and which steps need attention first. It is not a commitment to take action before you are ready.
The two possible paths after a fatal work injury
A fatal job injury may involve two different paths. The first is a workers’ compensation death-benefit claim. The second, when the facts support it, is a civil wrongful death claim against a negligent third party who was not the employer. These paths can proceed differently, but they can affect each other.
Workers’ compensation is usually the first system family members encounter. It is the process for seeking benefits connected to a work-related death. A civil wrongful death claim is different: it looks to a person or business outside the employer whose negligence may have caused the injury or death.
For example, a third party could be a negligent driver, a property owner, a contractor, a product manufacturer, or another nonemployer whose actions contributed to the fatal accident. Whether a third-party claim exists depends on the details. A fatal accident at work does not automatically mean that a third party is responsible, and a workers’ compensation claim does not prevent a careful review of that question.
The two paths should be considered together from the beginning. A third-party recovery can create issues for the workers’ compensation carrier’s lien, and the timing for a civil claim has its own Arizona rule. Our page on Arizona third-party work injury claims explains the basic role of a claim against a responsible nonemployer.
Death benefits for qualifying surviving family members
Death benefits are part of Arizona workers’ compensation when a worker dies from a job-related injury or illness. The central question is whether the death is connected to the work injury. The workers’ compensation claim also requires attention to which surviving family members qualify for benefits.
Who may qualify is not a question that should be answered by assumption. The worker’s relationship with a surviving spouse, children, and other possible dependents can matter, as can the facts of the family’s situation. An insurance carrier may ask for documents and information before it evaluates a claim. A clear record can help establish the claim accurately.
What death benefits cover also depends on the circumstances and the benefits available under the workers’ compensation claim. These benefits are distinct from a civil wrongful death recovery. Workers’ compensation benefits are handled through the compensation system, while a wrongful death claim against a third party addresses the responsibility of that outside party.
This distinction is important for surviving family members. A carrier may focus on its own workers’ compensation file, while a civil claim may need separate investigation of a crash, unsafe property, defective equipment, another contractor’s work, or another source of negligence. Keeping the issues organized can make it easier to understand what the family is being asked to decide.
If a loved one died while a prior workers’ compensation case was open, the existing claim materials may be important. Medical records, reports of the accident, wage information, notices from the carrier, and communications about prior benefits can all deserve review. Do not discard letters or settlement documents, even if they seem routine. They may help show what benefits have been paid and what lien issues could arise later.
When a third party caused the fatal accident
Under A.R.S. § 23-1023, if a work injury is caused by a negligent third party who is not the employer, the injured worker may pursue a civil claim against that third party. In a fatal work injury, surviving family members should have the circumstances reviewed promptly to determine whether a wrongful death third-party work injury claim needs attention.
The key distinction is that the potential defendant must be outside the employer. This may arise in a vehicle collision during work, an incident at another company’s location, a dangerous product, or work involving more than one business. The facts, contracts, and relationships can be complicated. A workers’ compensation-focused review can help separate the employer’s role from the possible role of another person or company.
A third-party claim can add a source of recovery that workers’ compensation death benefits alone may not provide. It can also require a separate assessment of fault, available insurance, evidence, and the effect of the workers’ compensation carrier’s lien. The purpose of an early review is not to make promises. It is to identify the available paths before an important deadline passes.
How the workers’ compensation lien affects survivors
When there is a recovery from a negligent third party, the workers’ compensation carrier holds a statutory lien under A.R.S. § 23-1023 for the compensation and medical benefits it paid. The lien attaches when the third-party case settles. It is not a collection fee.
The carrier is entitled to reimbursement only for medical expenses and indemnity, meaning lost-wage, payments. It is not entitled to reimbursement for legal fees, nurse case management, independent medical examinations, surveillance, or other non-recoverable costs. The amount actually collectable is the total recovery minus the reasonable and necessary expenses actually spent to secure that recovery, including attorney fees.
This can be easier to understand with the firm’s example. If a case settles for $90,000, the attorney fee is $30,000, and the workers’ compensation lien is $40,000, the client receives $20,000. The carrier then receives a credit for the $20,000 paid to the client. The carrier is responsible for pursuing that credit. If it does not do so and continues paying benefits, it cannot later demand repayment from the attorney or client after settlement.
Lien questions can be especially sensitive when a family is trying to understand what a third-party settlement will mean. Our Arizona workers’ compensation liens guide provides more detail about this separate issue.
There are additional protections that require planning. If a third-party settlement is less than the carrier’s lien, the worker must obtain the carrier’s written approval to settle. Proceeding without written approval can lead to serious penalties, including a possible claim for forfeiture of future workers’ compensation benefits. Arizona appellate courts have moved away from strict forfeiture over time, but some carriers still assert it. Written communication and early involvement of the carrier and its subrogation counsel can be important.
Arizona law can also allow a court to reduce a carrier’s lien to account for the employer’s comparative fault in a fair proceeding when an employee settles a third-party case for less than the third party liability insurance limits. This is a fact-specific issue. It should be addressed before a settlement is finalized, not treated as an afterthought.
The strict one-year deadline for a third-party claim
Arizona’s deadline for a third-party work injury claim is unusually important. The injured worker must pursue the third-party claim within one year of the injury. If that does not happen, the right to pursue the claim is automatically assigned to the workers’ compensation carrier, which may then pursue it. This differs from Arizona’s ordinary two-year personal injury deadline.
In a fatal work injury matter, this timing issue deserves attention even if the family is still working through the workers’ compensation death-benefit claim. Waiting for every question to be resolved can create a separate problem for a possible civil claim. An early consultation can identify the date of injury, the possible third parties, and the next steps without pressuring a family to make a rushed settlement decision.
As the one-year mark approaches, the worker or counsel can request a written reassignment of the third-party claim from the carrier. A written reassignment restores the right to the worker and preserves the additional year. Carriers often prefer to sign a reassignment rather than litigate a third-party case themselves, but it should be requested and documented in writing. Read more about the one-year deadline for Arizona third-party work injury claims.
What a civil wrongful death claim may add
Workers’ compensation death benefits and a civil claim do not serve the same role. A workers’ compensation claim concerns benefits within the compensation system. A civil wrongful death claim seeks recovery from a negligent nonemployer whose conduct caused or contributed to the fatal injury. Reviewing both paths can prevent an outside party’s responsibility from being overlooked.
A civil claim may allow the family to seek recovery from the third party, subject to the facts and applicable law. It can also require the family to address the workers’ compensation lien, a potential carrier credit, and any need for written carrier approval before settlement. These are not details to leave until papers are ready to sign.
Not every work-related death involves a viable third-party claim. Evidence may be incomplete, fault may be disputed, and insurance issues may be involved. That is why an unhurried assessment of the accident is useful. It can give you a clearer sense of what is known, what needs investigation, and which deadlines should be protected.
Uninsured and underinsured motorist proceeds are not lienable under A.R.S. § 23-1023 in the same way as third-party liability proceeds. Hospital liens are different from workers’ compensation liens as well. Arizona hospital liens arise under A.R.S. § 33-931, and their limitation and compromise are governed by A.R.S. § 33-937. Those issues should not be treated as though they are the same instrument.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I receive death benefits if my loved one died after a work accident?
Arizona workers’ compensation can provide death benefits when a worker dies from a job-related injury or illness, but whether a particular surviving family member qualifies depends on the family relationship and the facts. A review of the claim, the injury, and the family’s circumstances can help clarify what should be requested from the carrier.
Can our family bring a wrongful death claim as well as a workers’ compensation claim?
Possibly. A civil claim may be available when a negligent third party who was not the employer caused or contributed to the fatal work injury. The workers’ compensation claim and civil claim are separate paths, and a third-party recovery can affect the carrier’s lien.
Who counts as a third party after a fatal work accident?
A third party is a person or business other than the employer whose negligence may have caused the injury. Depending on the facts, that could include a driver, property owner, contractor, product manufacturer, or another nonemployer. The specific relationships should be reviewed carefully.
How long do we have to make a third-party claim in Arizona?
The worker must pursue the third-party claim within one year of the injury. If the claim is not pursued within that time, it is automatically assigned to the workers’ compensation carrier. A written reassignment may restore the right to the worker and preserve the additional year, so timing should be reviewed promptly.
Does the workers’ compensation carrier get all of a wrongful death settlement?
No. The carrier’s statutory lien covers the compensation and medical benefits it paid, not legal fees, nurse case management, independent medical examinations, surveillance, or other non-recoverable costs. The actual amount collectable is reduced by reasonable and necessary expenses, including attorney fees, actually spent to secure the recovery.
What if a third-party settlement is less than the workers’ compensation lien?
Written approval from the carrier is required before settling a third-party claim for less than the lien. Failing to obtain written approval can result in serious penalties, including a possible claim for forfeiture of future workers’ compensation benefits. This is a matter to address before agreeing to a settlement.
Speak with an Arizona workers’ compensation attorney
You deserve a calm conversation about the available options after a fatal work injury. Arizona’s Work Injury Firm offers a free consultation for surviving families, and there is no fee unless benefits are secured. Call (877) 370-5788 or contact Arizona’s Work Injury Firm to talk about the workers’ compensation claim and any possible third-party issue.
What Our Clients Are Saying!
Our unique approach to working with our clients
This Firm Stands Up for Working Families
“This law firm really stands up for working families; stands up for workers and will take your case and fight for your case. And get you the best possible settlement that you can have. You should trust in this law firm. This is the law firm that stood when the state was being challenged under SB1070 the anti-immigrant law.”
I Recommend This Firm To You
“Hi, my name is Ron Selma and I’ve been a client for a year and a half. Arizona’s Work Injury Firm, have been very professional for me and I would recommend this firm to anyone. They all are very professional.”
Injured On The Job
“My name is Jennifer Logan & I was injured on the job in January of 2013. Arizona’s Work Injury Firm came highly recommended from an attorney that I work for. I’ve been coming here ever since I consulted with him. He helped me out.”
In An Accident At Work
” Alex Carpio has been my attorney since the beginning in August of 2012. I was in an accident at work and I explained everything. At that point he said: “We’re going to continue & we’re going to go on with this because you do have a case.” I would recommend Alex Carpio very highly. He’s a great gentlemen and he listens.”
Arizona Workers Compensation Results
“I was injured on 10-1-2010. During that time I was in so much pain. I was really happy that I was able to find Arizona’s Work Injury Firm. If you look at my file I’ve over 3.5 years of paperwork. There’s no way that I would have been able to handle it on my own. They reminded me when I was supposed to go to court and took care of all the legal proceedings.”
We Recommend This Firm To You
“Hello, my name is Jorge Ramirez and my lawyer was Alex Carpio. He is a really good lawyer and I would recommend him to a lot of people. Arizona’s Work Injury Firm, have been very professional for me and my wife. Thank you Alex Carpio.”
At Arizona’s Work Injury Firm, we don’t identify you by your injury or your claim. We recognize you by name and by face. You have an important life with people who look up to you and depend on you. We treat you with that same respect. We will work with you on your Workers’ Compensation or Social Security Disability claims, helping you secure the benefits you deserve; affording you dignity today and hope for the future.